Advertisement
Transferring in-kind versus cashing out, plus keep in mind penalties due
Q: When transferring my unused RESP accumulated income into my RRSP, am I able to do it as is, i.e. bank stocks, or do I have to cash them in and transfer as cash?
—Johanna
A: If you end up with money in a Registered Education Savings Plan (RESP) that you can’t use for a child’s education, you can get back your original contributions tax-free.
The remaining Canada Education Savings Grant (CESG) money or Canada Learning Bond (CLB) money is repaid to the government, but that’s money you wouldn’t have had in the first place.
Ask a Planner: Leave your question for Jason Heath »
The excess accumulated income in an RESP is taxable upon withdrawal, plus a punitive 20% penalty tax. But as you have noted, Johanna, you can transfer up to $50,000 of this income to a Registered Retirement Savings Plan (RRSP) on a tax-deferred basis. This back-up option is one of the reasons I think an RESP far outshines other education savings options for children – like trust accounts – in addition to the 20%+ government grants.
To make the transfer from your RESP to your RRSP, Johanna, the RESP account must be at least 10 years old, all beneficiaries must be at least 21 years of age and none of the beneficiaries can be currently pursuing post-secondary education.
You also need to have RRSP room to transfer your unused RESP accumulated income into your RRSP. Although you won’t specifically get a tax deduction for the transfer, Johanna, it will help you avoid an income inclusion, so indirectly you will get a tax deduction. And since the tax payable would be at your regular tax rate plus a 20% penalty tax, it would almost always be advisable to make the transfer to your RRSP if possible.
Most Canadians have lots of RRSP room to absorb a transfer from an RESP, but if you don’t, there are things you can do to ensure you do.
If you are contributing to your RRSP currently and are nearly maxed out, slow down your contributions in advance of a transfer.
Or if you are a business owner and can take your compensation as salary instead of dividends to generate more RRSP room, this should be considered.
If you’re in a defined benefit (DB) pension plan, you may not have much RRSP room or generate much new RRSP room each year (perhaps as little as $600 of new RRSP room annually), but do your best to maximize your RRSP room and your eligible RESP transfer.
To clarify, Johanna, there are no capital gains taxes payable within an RESP, so your deferred capital gains on investments like your bank stocks in your RESP are irrelevant. The only tax factors are your original contributions and any government grants, with everything else being taxable as accumulated income on withdrawal.
On this basis, the only benefit to transferring investments in kind (as is) from an RESP to an RRSP are avoiding transaction costs. It saves you having to sell in one account and buy in another, incurring transaction costs like commissions to do so.
Although the Income Tax Act permits in-kind transfers in a case like this, practically speaking, not all financial institutions may permit you to do so as an administrative practice. If they require you to sell and repurchase, Johanna, you could always point out that in-kind transfers are allowed under the Income Tax Act and ask them if they can credit you back for any transaction costs you incur as a result.
Ask a Planner: Leave your question for Jason Heath »
Jason Heath is a fee-only, advice-only Certified Financial Planner (CFP) at Objective Financial Partners Inc. in Toronto, Ontario. He does not sell any financial products whatsoever.
MORE FROM A TAX EXPERT:
Share this article Share on Facebook Share on Twitter Share on Linkedin Share on Reddit Share on Email
Nvidia doubles revenue in one year, Canadian inflation moves in the wrong direction, Target misses badly, Walmart beats earnings...
Here’s how to get your free ticket to attend the MoneyShow virtual expo.
The Trump effect and Trumponomics, Shopify’s huge earnings beat, it’s sunny days for Suncor shareholders and more.
You started investing in your 20s, and you feel pretty good about doing it. But now what? Consider impact...
The U.S. election made the market go up—for now. Is volatility keeping you up at night? Here are some...
Apple and Nvidia vie for global market cap crown; Google, Microsoft and Meta crush earnings; Amazon’s Bezos takes WaPo...
The Bank of Canada’s jumbo rate cut, Canadian railway earnings stay on track, Rogers disappoints, and Tesla surges on...
U.S. banks post solid earnings, Walgreens cuts costs, United Airlines is flying high, Netflix still dominates streaming, and Canada’s...
Some strategies are time-sensitive, while others can help you start the new year on the right foot.
Further to this question, if contributor has NO RRSP Room, but has never used the permitted $2000 RRSP Over-contribution room, can you avoid the 20% penalty this way by transferring 2K into your RRSP, and then upon eventual withdrawal just have it taxable as any other RRSP withdrawal ?
Due to the large volume of comments we receive, we regret that we are unable to respond directly to each one. We invite you to email your question to [email protected], where it will be considered for a future response by one of our expert columnists. For personal advice, we suggest consulting with your financial institution or a qualified advisor.
Good day, Mr. Heath.
Over 20 years ago, my (then) husband and I purchased RESPs for our three pre-school daughters. We have not been together for over 15 years, however, both of our names are on this investment. Our daughters no longer require financial support for their education. The remaining funds will now be divided evenly between us. I am interested in transferring my portion to my grandchildren’s names and hoping it can remain in the same RESP. Can this be done? If yes, can my ex-husband’s name be removed leaving me as the sole owner? Can this transfer be done without loss of the government’s contribution? Or interest? Tax implications?
Thank you, Bethany
Due to the large volume of comments we receive, we regret that we are unable to respond directly to each one. We invite you to email your question to [email protected], where it will be considered for a future response by one of our expert columnists. For personal advice, we suggest consulting with your financial institution or a qualified advisor.