The fine art of rebalancing your investment portfolio

The fine art of rebalancing your portfolio

By Dan Bortolotti on May 23, 2019
Estimated reading time: 4 minutes

Rebalancing shouldn't be expected to boost returns, and even occasionally lowers them. But you should still do it—just not too often. Here’s why.

Science photo created by kues1 - www.freepik.com

Q. I started investing with the Couch Potato strategy two years ago. My question involves rebalancing. Would it be better or worse for returns to rebalance every month instead of once a year? I like being a hands-on investor and would not mind the extra time this would require, as long as there was the chance for a small increase in returns over 10 years or more. – Nicholas A. Even the Couch Potato strategy requires a little maintenance. Your asset allocation—that is, the targets you set for the percentage of stocks and bonds in your portfolio—will drift as markets move. So, from time to time, you may need to sell some of the assets that have gone up in value and use the proceeds to prop up whatever has lagged. For example, after a sharp downturn in the equity markets, you can sell some bonds and use the cash to buy more stocks. This is called rebalancing, and it’s an important part of any disciplined investment process. That said, rebalancing is often misunderstood. Its goal is not to boost returns; rather, it is primarily a risk management tool. Moreover, there is always a trade-off when rebalancing: It often incurs transaction costs and taxes, so rebalancing too frequently can be counterproductive. Let’s unpack these ideas a little. Remember that over the long term, stocks have a significantly higher expected return than bonds. So during most periods, rebalancing will involve selling stocks and buying bonds, not the other way around. For this reason, rebalancing a portfolio of stocks and bonds is therefore likely to lower your returns, not increase them. That said, you might expect a modest increase in returns when rebalancing asset classes that have a similar expected return, such as stocks from different countries. By occasionally selling high and buying low, there is a potential “rebalancing bonus.” But even this is likely to be modest. To test this, I ran the data for a portfolio with equal amounts of Canadian, U.S. and international stocks (all in Canadian dollars) from 1980 until the end of April 2019. It turns out that if you rebalanced this portfolio once a year, its annualized return over the entire period was 10.4%. And if you never rebalanced it at all? Exactly the same. (This shocked me, too.) If we look at only the last 10 years (ending April 2019), annually rebalancing an all-equity portfolio actually lowered performance, because U.S. stocks consistently outperformed Canadian and international, so you would have enjoyed higher returns had you just let them run. So if rebalancing should not be expected to boost returns—and if it occasionally lowers them—why do it at all? The answer is that rebalancing a portfolio is primarily designed to control risk. If you have a carefully designed plan that calls for a portfolio of, say, 60% stocks and 40% bonds, then you shouldn’t stray too far from those targets. If your portfolio drifts to 70% or 75% stocks, it would be meaningfully riskier than it was before, so the prudent thing to do is sell some stocks and buy some bonds to reduce that risk. So, I hope it’s clear why monthly rebalancing is much too frequent. Once a year is plenty in most cases. Even then, it’s not necessary to rebalance if your portfolio is only slightly askew. As a rule of thumb, consider rebalancing only when any asset class is more than five percentage points off its target. So if you are aiming for 40% bonds, you’re probably fine as long as you are within 35% to 45%. This is especially true if your portfolio is relatively small: for example, if you have $50,000 invested, each percentage point is just $500, which isn’t going to make a meaningful difference in terms of risk or potential return. Once your portfolio is very large, you can make an argument for rebalancing more frequently. If you are contributing to your portfolio regularly, you can use those cash flows to keep your portfolio balanced. Whenever you add new money, simply buy whichever asset is furthest below its target. During a year when U.S. equities have risen significantly and bonds have declined, for example, just direct your new contributions to the bonds. During a bear market, when stocks will likely fall below your target, use that new money to buy more equities. You will never keep your portfolio in perfect balance this way, but that’s not necessary. Rebalancing is like playing horseshoes: close is good enough. Dan Bortolotti, CFP, CIM, is an associate portfolio manager and financial planner with PWL Capital in Toronto.

Comments Cancel reply

Julia Hattori says:

August 14, 2020 at 3:55 pm

Thanks for your posts Dan. Much appreciated. I rebalance about 2x/year and find that’s enough.

Reply

Canadian couple outside of home, wondering if they should transfer it to their corporation.

Ask MoneySense

Is transferring your principal residence to your corporation a good idea?

Would swapping a house for cash from a corporation save on taxes? And is this tactic worth it in...

Is transferring your principal residence to your corporation a good idea?

Ask a Planner

RBC’s discount broker launches international trading—what to know before you invest

It’s a first among bank-owned discount brokers in Canada. With more banks likely to follow RBC's lead, what should...

RBC’s discount broker launches international trading—what to know before you invest

Ask a Planner

What are the tax implications if you resell Taylor Swift tickets?

Allison resold her Eras Tour tickets instead of going to the concert. The resale website asked for her SIN,...

What are the tax implications if you resell Taylor Swift tickets?

Ask a Planner

Should you take extra RRIF withdrawals to increase your estate?

Contrary to the conventional advice, taking more than the minimum RRIF withdrawal can at times save tax on your...

Should you take extra RRIF withdrawals to increase your estate?

Ask MoneySense

How much income can I earn while getting OAS?

If you continue working in retirement, it could cause a clawback on your OAS. Here’s how to figure out...

How much income can I earn while getting OAS?

Ask a Planner

Estate planning for singles—is a trust company the answer?

Canadians with no children or siblings must consider estate planning alternatives. Here’s why trust companies can be a good...

Estate planning for singles—is a trust company the answer?

Ask a Planner

What to know as Canada’s capital gains tax changes remain in legal limbo

The federal government’s capital gains inclusion rate increase has yet to become law. There’s a slight chance it may...

What to know as Canada’s capital gains tax changes remain in legal limbo

Ask a Planner

How to report foreign income in Canada

Canadians have reporting requirements for foreign assets, income and tax paid. Here’s how to claim each of these on...

How to report foreign income in Canada

Ask a Planner

Should you invest an inheritance in an RRSP or a TFSA?

A Certified Financial Planner provides perspective on the TFSA vs. RRSP question for a couple in their late 50s...

Should you invest an inheritance in an RRSP or a TFSA?

Ask a Planner

How to plan for taxes in retirement in Canada

In retirement, some income is not subject to withholding tax, and you may potentially owe tax after filing each...

How to plan for taxes in retirement in Canada

The fine art of rebalancing your portfolio

MORE FROM ASK AN INVESTMENT EXPERT:

Comments Cancel reply

Related Articles

Is transferring your principal residence to your corporation a good idea?

RBC’s discount broker launches international trading—what to know before you invest

What are the tax implications if you resell Taylor Swift tickets?

Should you take extra RRIF withdrawals to increase your estate?

How much income can I earn while getting OAS?

Estate planning for singles—is a trust company the answer?

What to know as Canada’s capital gains tax changes remain in legal limbo

How to report foreign income in Canada

Should you invest an inheritance in an RRSP or a TFSA?

How to plan for taxes in retirement in Canada