Advertisement
Stavros is worried that contributing an investment in kind to his TFSA will trigger the “superficial loss rule.”
Q. I just transferred 200 shares of an ETF from my margin account to my TFSA at a loss. Can I claim the loss, or does it fall into the 30-day rule?
–Stavros
A. Investments such as stocks, exchange-traded funds (ETFs) and mutual funds can generally be transferred “in-kind” between accounts, so that the investment is transferred from one account directly to the other without selling it. When an investment is transferred from a non-registered investment account, like a cash or margin account, into a tax-free savings account, the transfer is considered an eligible TFSA contribution. The contribution amount is based on the market value of the transferred investment at the time of transfer.
The “30-day rule” you are referring to, Stavros, is called the “superficial loss rule.” A superficial loss results when a capital loss is triggered in a taxable account, but the same investment is purchased in another account within 30 days before or after the loss is incurred.
The superficial loss rule applies to not only your repurchase of the investment, but also a repurchase by your spouse, a corporation you control, or a trust with you or your spouse as a beneficiary. The rule has been put in place to prevent Canadians from avoiding tax by selling an investment, only to have a partner or corporate repurchase it on their behalf.
In the case of a transfer of an investment from your non-registered margin account to your TFSA, Stavros, this does not result in a superficial loss. However, the Income Tax Act does deny a loss triggered on a deemed disposition of an investment at a loss upon transfer to a TFSA or registered retirement savings plan (RRSP). So, although the superficial loss rule would not apply, the result would be the same—your capital loss would be ineligible.
Interestingly, if you transfer an investment in kind that is trading at a capital gain, the capital gain is triggered and is taxable.
In order to successfully claim a capital loss, Stavros, you would need to sell an investment and transfer the resulting cash proceeds to your TFSA. This may result in transaction costs to sell, and additional transaction costs to reinvest in your TFSA. If the capital loss tax savings is more than the transaction costs, it probably makes sense to trigger a loss by selling and transferring cash.
If you want to repurchase the same investment in your TFSA, remember you must wait at least 30 days in order to do so, otherwise the superficial loss rules will apply even if you sell the investment before contributing.
You could always consider buying a similar investment instead of the same investment in order to get the cash invested without waiting. In other words, you could sell shares of one bank and buy shares of another bank. Or you could sell one U.S.-equity ETF and buy another comparable one.
Capital losses can only be claimed against capital gains on investments sold for a profit in taxable non-registered accounts. Tax savings can be as high as 27% of a capital loss. Capital losses can be claimed against current year capital gains, or if you have a net loss for the year, you can carry the loss back up to three years, or forward indefinitely.
So, I hate to be the bearer of bad news, Stavros, but your capital loss will be ineligible. Regardless, using non-registered investments to fund your TFSA contributions is sound tax planning, and now you know next time to sell before you contribute.
Jason Heath is a fee-only, advice-only Certified Financial Planner (CFP) at Objective Financial Partners Inc. in Toronto. He does not sell any financial products whatsoever.
MORE FROM ASK MONEYSENSE:
Watch: 4 things to consider before putting your money in a TFSA or RRSP
Share this article Share on Facebook Share on Twitter Share on Linkedin Share on Reddit Share on Email
Canadians with no children or siblings must consider estate planning alternatives. Here’s why trust companies can be a good...
The Trump effect and Trumponomics, Shopify’s huge earnings beat, it’s sunny days for Suncor shareholders and more.
You started investing in your 20s, and you feel pretty good about doing it. But now what? Consider impact...
Bitcoin surges, Coinbase makes a splash in Canadian football, and could bitcoin’s creator be Canadian?
The federal government’s capital gains inclusion rate increase has yet to become law. There’s a slight chance it may...
Canadians have reporting requirements for foreign assets, income and tax paid. Here’s how to claim each of these on...
Apple and Nvidia vie for global market cap crown; Google, Microsoft and Meta crush earnings; Amazon’s Bezos takes WaPo...
MoneySense’s editor-in-chief Lisa Hannam answers the My MoneySense questionnaire for MoneySense’s 25th anniversary.
If you are struggling with the higher cost of living in Canada and you need more income, you could...
That seems strange, turbo tax groups sell or transfer of stock and calculates the loss or gain?
Assuming Stavros had the funds in the TFSA, he could buy the 200 shares and next day sell 200 shares he had in his non registered account, then transfer the cash to the tfsa as new contribution. Because of the timing it doesn’t appear to trigger a superficial loss. He could claim the loss, which would only be beneficial if the tax saving is biger than the transactions’ cost.
Does that make sense?
So what if Stavros sold the 200 shares instead of transfering them, triggered a loss, then contributed the funds to his TFSA. Would that have made his loss eligible.
My investment institution views a transfer from one account to another as a sell and repurchase for tax purposes.
Due to the large volume of comments we receive, we regret that we are unable to respond directly to each one. We invite you to email your question to [email protected], where it will be considered for a future response by one of our expert columnists. For personal advice, we suggest consulting with your financial institution or a qualified advisor.
great article
A superficial loss occurs when you dispose of capital property for a loss and you, or a person affiliated with you, buys or has a right to buy the same or identical property during the period starting 30 calendar days before and ending 30 calendar days after the sale.
So to the comment of buying before selling below, that will not work
Why is it you have to declare capital gains for an in-kind transfer to a TFSA or RSP, but you can’t declare a capital loss? Seems illogical… then again, it’s CRA…