When you can ignore tracking errors

By Dan Bortolotti and Canadian Couch Potato on April 25, 2013
Estimated reading time: 3 minutes

In Monday's post, I reviewed the major factors that contribute to an index fund’s tracking error. Here are some other things to consider when you’re comparing your fund’s performance to that of its benchmark. These can cause tracking errors to seem unusually large or small, but they need to be understood in context.

This article is 3 years old. Some details may be outdated.

In Monday’s post, I reviewed the major factors that contribute to an index fund’s tracking error. Here are some other things to consider when you’re comparing your fund’s performance to that of its benchmark. These can cause tracking errors to seem unusually large or small, but they need to be understood in context. Changes to the index. A number of ETFs changed their benchmark index during 2012, including some core equity funds from BMO and Vanguard. When there is an index change in the middle of the year, measuring tracking error becomes difficult and the numbers can be misleading. Until late September, the BMO S&P 500 Hedged to CAD (ZUE) held just 100 large-cap stocks selected using a different methodology. ZUE ended up lagging the S&P 500 by less than its management fee, which is normally an excellent result, but in this case it was a fluke. A small number of ETFs in Canada are not tied to any third-party benchmark. The BMO Canadian Dividend (ZDV), for example, includes 30 stocks selected using an in-house methodology. In cases like this, there’s not much you can do other than compare the fund’s performance to other Canadian dividend ETFs, or perhaps to a broad market index such as the S&P/TSX Composite. Even then, this will only be meaningful over multi-year periods. Differences between market price and NAV. Last month I explained how an ETF’s market price can differ from its net asset value (NAV). In most cases, tracking error is measured by comparing the index return to the fund’s NAV. But things get complicated when a Canadian ETF holds an underlying US-listed ETF, a structure that’s common at iShares and Vanguard. Now you’ve got two different ETFs with two different NAVs and two different market prices. Most of the large tracking error in the Vanguard MSCI U.S. Broad Market (VUS) was likely the result of currency hedging, but its annual report also cites “differences between the market price and net asset value of the underlying US domiciled Vanguard funds in which the ETF invests.” Don’t be concerned about this sort of tracking error: it’s a short-term anomaly that would disappear if you used different start and end dates. Fair value pricing. One of the reasons an international equity ETF’s market price and NAV can diverge is time zone differences, as I explained in a recent post. This same phenomenon can also cause the ETF’s tracking error to appear unusually large, something I first wrote about back in 2010. Vanguard uses a technique called fair value pricing to correct for some of these distortions, and this idea is described in the most recent annual report for its emerging markets ETF (VEE):

The ETF’s management fees subtracted 0.54 percentage points from the fund’s performance. Other factors, such as security selection and fair-value pricing, added back 0.46 percentage points. Fair-value pricing is a policy intended to address pricing discrepancies that may arise because of time-zone differences among global stock markets. This policy ensures that the ETF’s net asset value doesn’t include “stale” prices from markets that close before the U.S. stock market.

The key point here is that if your ETF happened to show a large tracking error recently, that’s not necessarily a reason to abandon it. It’s critical to check the fund’s Management Report of Fund Performance to determine the explanation. As with so many investing decisions, tracking error should be considered with a focus on the long-term.

Comments Cancel reply

Canadian Crypto Observer

Is now a good time to buy bitcoin?

In the face of tariffs and economic uncertainty, is bitcoin a safe haven asset? Plus, gold vs. bitcoin, and...

Is now a good time to buy bitcoin?

Ask a Planner

How to avoid RRSP overcontributions when you have a deferred profit sharing plan

Maxing out employer contributions is an easy way to boost your retirement savings. Here’s how to do it without...

How to avoid RRSP overcontributions when you have a deferred profit sharing plan

A Canadian family moving, thanks the BoC rate cuts, which improved mortgage affordability in Vancouver, Toronto and Hamilton

Mortgages

How much income do you need to buy a home in Canada? A look at home affordability in March 2025

Ask MoneySense

Should I draw down my RRIF to avoid estate taxes?

Yes, your estate will pay a high rate of tax on your RRIF when you die. But it usually...

Should I draw down my RRIF to avoid estate taxes?

Ask a Planner

Can you make RRSP contributions after age 71?

Here’s why you might see an RRSP deduction limit on your notice of assessment, even when you’ve already converted...

Can you make RRSP contributions after age 71?

Hand holding a caution sign, symbolizing the Bank of Canada's caution messages with this week's rate hold.

Mortgages

Making sense of the Bank of Canada interest rate decision on April 16, 2025

Canadian man at 71 thinking about his RRIF withdrawal plan on a walk.

Retired Money

How to make sure you have enough money to fund your RRIF withdrawals

Once you start RRIFing, how do you make sure you have enough cash, and should you dial down risk?

How to make sure you have enough money to fund your RRIF withdrawals

Ask a Planner

2024 tax-filing extensions: What you need to know

There are several personal, trust and corporate income-tax-filing extensions for Canadians this year. Which ones apply to you? ...

2024 tax-filing extensions: What you need to know

A Canadian landlord showing a property to potential tenants for the 2025 tax year.

Income Properties

Rental income and taxes: What’s new for Canadian property owners in 2025

Whether you have renters in your home or another property, know that the money you make can affect your...

Rental income and taxes: What’s new for Canadian property owners in 2025

A Canadian woman with friends, whom she is considering creating a corporation to invest.

Ask a Planner

Should you set up a corporation with friends to invest?

What to consider when deciding to incorporate a company with friends to buy real estate and more.

Should you set up a corporation with friends to invest?

When you can ignore tracking errors

Comments Cancel reply

Related Articles

Is now a good time to buy bitcoin?

How to avoid RRSP overcontributions when you have a deferred profit sharing plan

How much income do you need to buy a home in Canada? A look at home affordability in March 2025

Should I draw down my RRIF to avoid estate taxes?

Can you make RRSP contributions after age 71?

Making sense of the Bank of Canada interest rate decision on April 16, 2025

How to make sure you have enough money to fund your RRIF withdrawals

2024 tax-filing extensions: What you need to know

Rental income and taxes: What’s new for Canadian property owners in 2025

Should you set up a corporation with friends to invest?