Are auto insurance premiums cheapest in August?

Q: I have read that your auto insurance premiums will be cheapest if you sign up in August. Is this true? And if so, should I consider doing this?

—Isabel B. in Ontario

Compare personalized quotes from Canada's top car insurance providers.All in under 5 minutes with ratehub.ca. Let's get started.*

Get free quotes

You will be leaving MoneySense. Just close the tab to return.

A: Thanks for your question, Isabel. If you want the quick answer, no, it’s not true. It’s a great click bait title but not a strategy for savings.

READ: How to cut your auto insurance costs

Auto insurance rates are approved by the Financial Services Commission of Ontario (FSCO) which has in place a defined application process. Insurance companies need to submit the financials to the government regulator who approves or denies rate increases.

Rates can only be changed quarterly and you can see the changes dating back to 1999 here.

Insurance companies are capped at a maximum amount of profit and they cannot increase rates willy-nilly whenever they want. For an insurance company to receive approval for a rate increase it must be able to show that it has actually had losses in one of the categories—home, auto, etc.

FSCO states that when considering setting rates it will review with its actuaries all the insurance companies’ details in its proposal and data to make sure as per the law, that it is:

just and reasonable;
not excessive; and
not going to impair a company’s financial solvency

Now, when an insurance company has a total rate increase of 1% on its entire book of business, that could mean a lot of different things for all of its customers. Some customers in that book of business will see an 8% increase while others see a 7% decrease. Often the changes are applied per territory but could include one of the hundreds of rating variables used to calculate the different prices.

Two of the very current trends that are affecting auto insurance rates are the increased property damage cost and distracted driving, as the amount of sensors and electronics in cars has gone up substantially in recent years. A bumper that used to be under $1,000 to repair is now several thousand with all the backup and camera sensors in it, and a windshield that has the cameras and radar in it or heads-up display can be thousands instead of the $300 for the glass that it used to cost. The second increase in frequency is due to all the distracted driving and cell phone use that is causing accidents.

Now that you’ve read this far, what is a winning strategy to save money responsibly?

Here is the FSCO suggestion: “Consumers are urged to shop around for auto insurance.”

Summed up then, there are about 40 insurance companies for home and auto insurance that collect a majority of the premiums. Each of those companies can change rating and pricing variables four times a year. It’s extremely competitive and changes often. No one company is the best for all drivers— or even for a substantial period of time.

Add to that the fact that your commute and driving record changes as you gain experience, or get driving tickets and points changes, and it gets complicated.

Still, you have two options to stay on top of it.

Option 1: Take on researching the market on your own visiting individual websites and making calls to get all the rates and do your own comparison.

Alternatively, there’s Option 2: Work with a broker that has 40 plus markets and can track it for you and give you an update on auto insurance rates in general and for your specific case whenever you want. Those are really the only two ways for motorists to stay current on the ever-changing auto insurance market and premium changes for drivers.

Adam Mitchell is the president of Mitchell & Whale insurance brokers in Ontario.